Your watch is guessing your zones.
Most watches build your training zones from a formula based on your age. Here's why that can be a long way out, and how to replace the guess with a number.
Open the heart-rate zones on almost any watch and you'll find five tidy bands. They look precise. For most people they're built on a guess.
Where the guess comes from
Most watches start from your maximum heart rate, and most estimate that from your age. The classic formula is 220 minus your age. A large review in 2001 found that 208 minus 0.7 times your age fits the average better. Either way it's an average. Real people commonly sit 10 beats or more either side of it.
Then the watch takes fixed percentages of that number to make zones. That adds a second guess on top of the first. Two runners with the same maximum heart rate can have aerobic thresholds a long way apart, because the threshold depends on how you've trained, not on your maximum.
What it costs you
If your Zone 2 is set ten beats too high, every easy run is a bit too hard. You recover less, your hard sessions suffer, and you wonder why you're tired. If it's set too low, you shuffle along and miss fitness you could have had.
Neither shows up as an error. The watch still says "Zone 2" in the same confident font.
How to replace the guess
You need two numbers: your aerobic threshold (the top of easy) and your threshold (the hardest effort you can hold for about an hour).
- In a lab: a gas-analysis or lactate test measures both directly.
- On your own: a 30-minute time trial gives a good estimate of your threshold heart rate, and a steady one-hour drift test tells you whether a given heart rate is above or below your aerobic threshold.
Neither field test is perfect. Both are far better than your date of birth.
Know which numbers to trust
Whatever you use, keep track of where each number came from. A measured threshold, a field-tested one and a formula's estimate are not the same thing, and they shouldn't look the same on your screen. That's the idea Athlete OS is built on: every number is labelled lab measured, field tested or estimated.
Want a starting point today? Try the free Zone 2 calculator, then test it.
Source: Tanaka H, Monahan KD, Seals DR. Age-predicted maximal heart rate revisited. Journal of the American College of Cardiology, 2001.
Train on your own numbers
Athlete OS builds your zones from your tests, tells you after every session whether it did its job, and shows when your fuel runs out. See it with a sample athlete, no signup.
Open the demo