Heart rate, pace or feel? Use all three.
Each way of measuring effort has a blind spot. Put an internal measure, an external measure and feel together and they cover for each other.
"Should I train by heart rate or pace?" is one of the questions I'm asked most. The honest answer is that each one has a blind spot, and the best approach uses three measures together.
Internal: what it costs your body
Heart rate (and lactate, if you've been tested) tells you what an effort is costing you. It's personal and it reflects the day you're having.
Its blind spot: it moves for reasons that have nothing to do with your fitness. Poor sleep, dehydration, heat, stress, a drink the night before and caffeine can all push it up. It also lags. In a three-minute rep, your heart rate is still climbing when the rep ends.
External: what you're putting out
Pace, or power on the bike, tells you what you're actually producing. It responds straight away and it's the same today as it was last week.
Its blind spot: it ignores how you're coping. The same pace can be easy on a good day and hard on a bad one. And pace means little on hills, trails or in wind.
Feel: what it's like inside
Effort out of 10 and the talk test work anywhere, on any terrain, with no equipment.
Its blind spot: it takes practice, and most of us are optimistic. People routinely call a moderate run "easy".
Put them together
Use one as the target and the other two as guardrails.
- Short, hard reps: go by pace. Heart rate is too slow to catch up.
- Threshold and tempo: go by pace, with a heart-rate cap so a good day doesn't turn it into a race.
- Easy and long runs: go by heart rate. Let the pace be whatever it is.
- Hills and trails: heart rate and feel. Ignore pace.
When two of the three agree, trust them. When they disagree, that's information. If your heart rate is ten beats high at your usual easy pace, something's off: sleep, heat, illness or fatigue. Ease off and find out why.
That's how Athlete OS sets each session: one target, by whichever measure suits it, a guardrail, and a feel line as a backup.
Train on your own numbers
Athlete OS builds your zones from your tests, tells you after every session whether it did its job, and shows when your fuel runs out. See it with a sample athlete, no signup.
Open the demoNext: Why Zone 2 means something different when you're fitter.